The Best Toy Mystery Boxes
Getting what you want is always nice, but the thrill of the unknown is sometimes even more fun. That’s why some of us enjoy surprise parties, twisted movie endings, and opening packs of trading cards. If you want to bring a sense of mystery to your Amazon order, a mystery toy box may be a great way to do it. Whether it’s for you or a loved one, we’ve rounded up the best mystery toy boxes available on the market to help narrow down your search for a surprise.
What to Look For
When narrowing down the best mystery toy boxes on the market, we considered the type of toy, entertainment value, size/quantity, and price. For example, if you want to test your luck with a set of five randomly selected plush toys, the Squishmallow 5-pack plush mystery box offers cute and cuddly toys that are collectible for even more fun. If you want something a bit more affordable, the Sunny Days Entertainment 8-piece surprise box comes with a wide variety of different toys, with hundreds of available combinations at a great price. Read on to see all our top picks and find the one that’s right for you.
Squishmallow 5-Pack Plush Mystery Box
The more the merrier
If you want to give your little ones a new cuddly companion for nap time but you’re not sure what kind of plush toy to get, why not get a variety? This plush toy mystery box from Squishmallow features five different plush toys, each with a cute design and a super-soft exterior. Each toy is about five inches wide, and they feature a whole assortment of different animals, designs, and colors. These plush toys are great for boys and girls, and with so many different options, it’s hard to go wrong with this mystery box. They may be more expensive than the competition, but it’s worth it for the quality of these cuddly toys.
Pros:
- Extremely soft
- Comes with five different plush toys
- Great for boys and girls
- Cute designs
Cons:
- More expensive than other mystery boxes
L.O.L. Surprise! Mega Gift Box Surprise
Play dress up
It can be hard to keep your little ones entertained without a variety of toys to choose from, but luckily this mystery box picks randomly from more than 25 available options spanning different brands to bring you a unique surprise box. These toys range from dolls and accessories to all the cute add-ons to go along with them. On top of a great selection, it also sports adorable packaging. If you have a daughter looking to add to her doll collection or beauty items, this surprise box may be just what she needs for a new twist.
Pros:
- Choices from more than 25 surprises
- Includes at least one L.O.L. Surprise! toy
- Features products from different brands
- Cute packaging
- Perfect gifts for girls
Cons:
- Each box only has about five items
Funko Pop! Mystery Minis: Five Nights at Freddy’s
Size matters
Funko Pops are some of the most popular collectible figurines on the market, and these minis are no exception. With 12 different figurines based on the Five Nights at Freddy’s video game, there are plenty of choices for your randomly selected mystery box. Each figurine is made of vinyl and is approximately two inches tall, so they’re perfectly sized for displaying on a desk or shelf for all to see. Best of all, they come at a low price per box, so you can buy just one or collect them all. For fans of the video game, this bargain is hard to beat.
Pros:
- Low price
- Wide variety of different figurine options
- Made with vinyl
- Great for kids
- Based on the Five Nights at Freddy’s video game
Cons:
- The price is low but can add up if you collect multiple figures.
Aphmau MeeMeows Mystery Plush
Cute and cuddly
Plush animals can be a fun way to get cozy when you’re going to sleep, but they also double as playable toys. With this mystery plush box from Aphmau, you can get your very own MeeMeow to snuggle and play with. Each one features a cute design, with options from 8 possible MeeMeow cats. Whether you’re a fan of the Aphmau YouTube channel or you just love cute stuffed animals, this mystery plush box has something for everyone.
Pros:
- Based on a popular YouTube gaming channel
- Options from 8 possible MeeMeows
- Colorful designs
- Choices from three different series
Cons:
- The plush toys are fairly small for the price
Sunny Days Entertainment 8-Piece Surprise Box
Don't break the bank
It can be hard to find toys that offer good value for the money, but with this mystery box from Sunny Days Entertainment, you can get eight toys in a portable, reusable box for a low price. Each box comes with a totally unique collection of toys, so there are literally hundreds of options for what random box you’ll get. The items range from bubbles, bracelets, model airplanes, and more. Best of all, you can keep them in the surprise box and take them with you on your travels. It acts as a toy box and carrying case all in one. If you want to get the most bang for your buck, this mystery toy box is a sure winner.
Pros:
- The box has a portable handle design
- Comes with eight different toys in each box
- Every single box is unique
- Great price
Cons:
- Toys are cheaper quality than some other options
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if I get a mystery toy I don’t like?
If the toy just comes in a pack of one, you could return the toy and try your luck with a new purchase. However, if it’s a multi-pack and there’s just one of the toys that you don’t want, you would have to return all of them to try again. That’s just the luck of the draw.
Are mystery toys more affordable than choosing the toy you want?
Not necessarily. Sometimes when clothing brands do a mystery grab bag, it comes at a more affordable price because it’s all merchandise that they’re trying to move out of their warehouses. It’s not always the same with toys. Most function as a sort of variety pack with collectible items, whether they’re trading cards or figurines, so they normally sell for full price.
About the Author
Why Trust Us
With the constantly shifting landscape in the world of technology, GameRevolution seeks to provide gamers and tech-enthusiasts with the information they need to select the right products for their needs. Since 1996, our experts have used their knowledge on all the latest gadgets – everything from headphones to standing desks – to help millions of people navigate specs and answer common questions.